So, you send Batman to deal with a meteor, Wonder Woman to solve a mystery, and Superman to end a war, right?
The name of the game is to send a (usually competent) hero or heroine into a situation where they are completely ill-equipped to help. Maybe a villain hacked dispatch that day? The Justice League got its roster wrong? Who knows!
For our first scenario, we have a school on fire. Someone has to come help! Who shouldn’t lend their aid?