Here is how I list the shows…
#1 Titans. THIS is, in my opinion, the best DC show. It just “clicks” with me in terns of acting, pacing and writing.
#2 Lucifer; gonna miss this show when it ends.
#3 Flash Still a good show, but over use of “speedsters” has made Flash not so unique a hero. Ralph and Vibe are funny together.
#4 Black Lightning I really like this show. If it can put in a good second season, it will go higher
#5 Legends I am liking Legends, but the silly factor keeps it in fourth BUT…I really like the show.
1-5 is the cut off. I like each of those shows; some more than others…but I like them all. The next three are trailing for various reasons.
#6 Gotham; Losing steam in my opinion. The "is he joker is he not joker’ jumped the shark me.
#7 Arrow First three season were pretty good then…well…it did keep the candle lit after Smallville bowed out…so it will be remembered for that.
#8 Supergirl I miss Cat Grant. Show just isn’t the same with out her IMO. Wears its politics on its sleeves, which is fine if you’re into that; I’m not.