I actually found this comic yesterday!
Hal is definitely #1 for me with John at #2. I actually think Hal is fun to read (when well written), and I like the bravado. It reminds me of Captain Kirk and Indiana Jones. I’d put Guy and Kyle in slots #3-4, and probably Jo at #5. Of the newer Lanterns she seems the most interesting to me. Since she wasn’t included on the list (is Far Sector an alt universe? I think Bruce Wayne and Dick Grayson got rings in some corner of the multiverse too…), I’d probably put Simon in that slot.
True, no competition