Look, let’s be honest here. Arrow, Gotham, and Titans consist largely of the writers reminding the audience how much they wish they were writing a Batman show. I doubt Batwoman will be any different.
So, if it makes them stop doing that, fine. Just make a Batman show. Yeah, he’s overexposed, but I’m sick of shows that are almost Batman shows but not quite, but then obsess over the fact that they’re almost about Batman. So, a show about Batman starring Batman fighting the Joker and Two-Face in live action. Just let them get it out of their systems for a season or two.
Wonder Woman: The Animated Series. People were talking about this in another thread, and I’d definitely be up for it. Ares seems like the obvious villain, but I see him almost as more of a background threat, more equivalent to Ra’s al Ghul and Darkseid than to the Joker and Lex Luthor. Instead, I’d prefer the Cheetah as the main villain, potentially with Circe involved in a subplot to set her up as the villain for the second season. This would be on the more PG end.
Justice Society of America. Maybe just call it JSA. I’m imagining a live action period piece set in the '40s as they battle people like Per Degaton, Vandal Savage, and the Ultra-Humanite, while also dealing with real-world issues like World War II and the Red Scare. Probably more on the MA side.
Justice League International. Alright, this one isn’t very likely, but I can dream, right? It could be animated or live action. I imagine if it were animated, it would skew in a more humorous, PG direction with some of the goofier villains like Lord Manga Khan. If it were live action, it should still be funny, but a bit more mature and rely on a more serious villain like Kilg%re.
Shazam! The Animated Series. PG, and go all out on the weird plots and goofy villains. I want Mister Mind as the main bad guy, Mister Tawky Tawny in all his nonsensical glory, and lots of “Curses! Foiled again!” Mostly so that things can suddenly, shockingly, and dramatically get really dark when Black Adam shows up. But, like, not MA dark.
Showcase! Probably animated, but if they had the budget, it could be really cool in live action (though live action can actually be quite limiting for the superhero genre). Basically, I’m imagining a sort of anthology series where each episode introduces the viewer to a different DC character, possibly with a mix of better-known characters to get people watching and more obscure ones to give them some publicity. Or do what Batman: The Brave and the Bold did and have every episode be a team-up of a better-known character and a more obscure one, as long as it’s not always Batman - don’t get me wrong, I love Batman and BTBATB is great, but I don’t want to just recycle that show’s gimmick. Maybe have it be something along the lines of every episode featuring at least one of the Big Five (Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, the Flash, and Green Lantern) and one other character. It would theoretically be episodic, but it could be really cool if there were actually subplots that ran through multiple episodes and tied together. Maybe you could even have each season be a collection of apparently distinct stories that tie together at the finale, like the TV equivalent of 52. Or if you go with the team-up idea, maybe each major hero has an ongoing plot that a series of more obscure ones help them with. I think this should probably be MA, though it would still work as a PG thing.